All the Big Stars

FUSE TV - All the Big Stars

Hype Williams' video for Kanye West's "All of the Lights" opens with a shot of dozens of names on a board. That might be a joke about the song itself: besides West and top-billed co-stars Rihanna and Kid Cudi, the recording features performances by Elton John, Drake, John Legend, The-Dream, Alicia Keys and a host of other middling-to-huge names, most of them shunted into the chorus. (Rihanna's outfit, surprisingly, doesn't get a credit of its own, despite providing an indelible reinterpretation of her line "want you to see everything.") And, as a consequence, "All of the Lights" runs into one of the trickiest problems in songcraft: how to construct a four-minute piece that lets a whole lot of different voices each get a star turn.

Usually, the words to pop songs are lyrics in the sense of "lyric poetry." If one voice is out front, the idea is that that person is speaking either as himself or herself, or as a character. (Maybe there are backup singers, or people singing harmony, but they're just emphasizing whatever the lead vocalist is doing.) Simple, right? Two people singing is a little trickier. It can be a conversational duet—the sort of thing George Jones and Tammy Wynette used to do—or two perspectives on the same thing, a la Sleater-Kinney. The latter works particularly well if one voice is singing and another one's rapping, as with, say, Jay-Z and Alicia Keys' "Empire State of Mind"; that's why hip-hop and R&B hits tend to have a "feat." somewhere in their titles these days.

Three people? Making that kind of conversation work in the space of a pop song is tougher, although even spotlight-lover Kanye has been part of a great one-off trio: on Twista's "Slow Jamz," he and Twista and Jamie Foxx all managed to carve out space of their own. Four? That's even trickier: most groups with more than a few vocalists tend to only have a couple of them take a spotlight turn within a single song. (The Bangles had four lead singers, but they usually alternated songs, and only three of them got solo verses on "Walk Like an Egyptian"; the Traveling Wilburys had five singers, but only a few of them sang lead on any given song, even "Handle With Care.")

Beyond that, you're getting into "Do They Know It's Christmas?" territory, or something like the Bonzo Dog Doo-Dah Band's "The Intro and the Outro," from 1967: the joke is that it spends so much time introducing all its guest musicians ("Adolf Hitler on vibes. Nice!... Over there, Eric Clapton, ukulele... Count Basie Orchestra on triangle") that it never actually gets around to being a song.

In fact, the only real attempt at a group that gave more than three singers a chance to elbow each other off the microphone within each song didn't last long at all. Assembled in 1968, the Soul Clan consisted of five killer R&B vocalists—organizer Don Covay, Solomon Burke, Ben E. King, Joe Tex and Arthur Conley—who'd all been pretty successful on their own. When it came time to make their first collective single, though, the Clan members never even managed to be in the same place at the same time. Don Covay assembled the backing track; the others recorded their parts individually. The A-side, "Soul Meeting," cracked the charts, scraping its way up to #34 R&B; the B-side, "That's How It Feels," is something of a cult item. There was an album credited to the group, but it was really just those two songs plus a couple of solo tracks by each of the members. In fact, that first single was all they ever managed to record collectively.

The lineup on "All of the Lights" is hardly a "group," just a one-off assemblage—and, under the circumstances, it's not surprising that the track ends up being dominated by Kanye's presence. Every time Rihanna's singing, or Kid CuDi's crooning, or somebody else is chiming in, it's just marking time until 'Ye gets back out in front. The point of its arrangement—bringing in a whole credit sequence's worth of stars to glimmer for a few moments and be gone—may simply be that he's the light who gets to shine brightest.

An All Star Women Special

46m

An All Star Women Special

The All-Americans

1h 36m

The All-Americans

The Big Break-Up

21m

The Big Break-Up

The All-Americans - Trailer

2m

The All-Americans - Trailer

All in the Family

20m

All in the Family

The Exclusive Premiere of Big Freedia's New Music Video, "BigFoot"

3m

The Exclusive Premiere of Big Freedia's New Music Video, "BigFoot"

All the Focus is on the Diamonds

21m

All the Focus is on the Diamonds

Big Bear 2: The Wrath of Tito

23m

Big Bear 2: The Wrath of Tito

Poppin' Up All Over The Place

20m

Poppin' Up All Over The Place

Big Freedia

21m

Big Freedia

Big Boi

20m

Big Boi

Operation Big Bear

23m

Operation Big Bear

A Big Splash

21m

A Big Splash

Cam'ron Unveils The All-Pink Fleebok 2

2m

Cam'ron Unveils The All-Pink Fleebok 2

All the Best Moments From Saturday Morning Fever

2m

All the Best Moments From Saturday Morning Fever

The Transcendent Star On Donald Trump: Dear Bambiana

1m

The Transcendent Star On Donald Trump: Dear Bambiana

The Star Gets Real About Breast Implants: Dear Bambiana

1m

The Star Gets Real About Breast Implants: Dear Bambiana

Big Bad Voodoo Finale

21m

Big Bad Voodoo Finale

Big Freedia Means Business

21m

Big Freedia Means Business

Big Freedia Means Business

Big Freedia Means Business

All About Nina

1h 36m

All About Nina

All Joking Aside

1h 20m

All Joking Aside

Big Freedia: Queen Of Bounce

Big Freedia: Queen Of Bounce

All Joking Aside - Trailer

1m

All Joking Aside - Trailer

All About Nina - Trailer

1m

All About Nina - Trailer

Big Freedia’s Twerk of Art

20m

Big Freedia’s Twerk of Art

Big Trouble In Little Chinese Restaurant

9m

Big Trouble In Little Chinese Restaurant

Big Freedia: Queen of Bounce - Trailer

1m

Big Freedia: Queen of Bounce - Trailer

If Clash of the Corps Stars Could Role-Play For A Day

1m

If Clash of the Corps Stars Could Role-Play For A Day

What Does The Transcendent Star Look For In A Man: Dear Bambiana

1m

What Does The Transcendent Star Look For In A Man: Dear Bambiana

All You Ever Wished For

1h 21m

All You Ever Wished For

One Big Happy Family: Season 2 Trailer

2m

One Big Happy Family: Season 2 Trailer

Amanda Cerny and Big Freedia Sh!tshow

20m

Amanda Cerny and Big Freedia Sh!tshow

Fuse+ is the Home for Big Freedia Means Business, Sex Sells, Made From Scratch & More!

30s

Fuse+ is the Home for Big Freedia Means Business, Sex Sells, Made From Scratch & More!

All You Ever Wished For - Trailer

2m

All You Ever Wished For - Trailer

We All Have That One Family Member...

3m

We All Have That One Family Member...

T-Pain's School of Business: Artiphon- The All In One Musical Device | Season 1 Look Back |

1m

T-Pain's School of Business: Artiphon- The All In One Musical Device | Season 1 Look Back |

Hip-Hop Stars & NBA Legends Signature Sneakers

6m

Hip-Hop Stars & NBA Legends Signature Sneakers

Need Advice? Ask 'Transcendent' Star Bambiana Anything

34s

Need Advice? Ask 'Transcendent' Star Bambiana Anything

Big Freedia & Adie Share Their Resilience Following Hurricane Katrina

3m

Big Freedia & Adie Share Their Resilience Following Hurricane Katrina

Where Did People Get All These Milk Crates?

21m

Where Did People Get All These Milk Crates?

Carlos Niño Shares His All-Time Favorite Record

2m

Carlos Niño Shares His All-Time Favorite Record

Big Freedia Meets Her Puppet: Hollywood Puppet Shitshow First Date

1m

Big Freedia Meets Her Puppet: Hollywood Puppet Shitshow First Date

Does Finance Talk Stress You Out? Amara La Negra & Sharelle Rosado Tell All

5m

Does Finance Talk Stress You Out? Amara La Negra & Sharelle Rosado Tell All

The River and the Wall

1h 45m

The River and the Wall

The Beatles: In the Life

1h 2m

The Beatles: In the Life

Puppet Hot Tub Aftershow Episode 3: Big Freedia and Amanda Cerny Step Into Wilmer's Hot Tub

7m

Puppet Hot Tub Aftershow Episode 3: Big Freedia and Amanda Cerny Step Into Wilmer's Hot Tub

The Blue Devils Bring The Parade

1m

The Blue Devils Bring The Parade

The Best of The Best Clash

2m

The Best of The Best Clash

The Motorcycle

23m

The Motorcycle

The Citizen

1h 34m

The Citizen

The Reunion

45m

The Reunion

The Decision

44m

The Decision

The Hustle

20m

The Hustle

The Pilot

21m

The Pilot

The Exchange

1h 27m

The Exchange

The FP

1h 20m

The FP

The Canvas

The Canvas

The 212

The 212

The Feels

1h 21m

The Feels

The Ladies Play "Fill In The Blanks"

1m

The Ladies Play "Fill In The Blanks"

The Hilarious Reality of the American Rat Race

2m

The Hilarious Reality of the American Rat Race

Out With The Old, In With The New

20m

Out With The Old, In With The New

The North Shore

22m

The North Shore

The Sex Clinic

The Sex Clinic

Cassandro, The Exotico!

1h 15m

Cassandro, The Exotico!

Free The Robots

9m

Free The Robots

Mind the Mints

21m

Mind the Mints

The Read - Trailer

57s

The Read - Trailer

Surfing the Skies

22m

Surfing the Skies

The Glow Up

20m

The Glow Up

Create The Future

20m

Create The Future

The 212 - Trailer

59s

The 212 - Trailer

The Winner Is…

44m

The Winner Is…

The Right Girls

1h 22m

The Right Girls

The Third Strike

1h 3m

The Third Strike

Rock the Bells

21m

Rock the Bells

Behind The Snow

22m

Behind The Snow

Meet The Jets

48m

Meet The Jets

The Great Director

23m

The Great Director

Into The Woods

21m

Into The Woods

Enter the Metaverse

21m

Enter the Metaverse

The Vest Guest

20m

The Vest Guest

Pink: The Truth

57m

Pink: The Truth

The Daphne Project

1h 7m

The Daphne Project

The Revolution Generation

1h 17m

The Revolution Generation

Crossed the Line

1h 30m

Crossed the Line

Rich The Kid

20m

Rich The Kid

Facing The Truth

20m

Facing The Truth

Making The Retrograde

20m

Making The Retrograde

Between the Shades

1h 22m

Between the Shades

Who's the Boss?

24m

Who's the Boss?

Making the Cut

46m

Making the Cut

The Feels - Trailer

1m

The Feels - Trailer

Missy: The Icon

20m

Missy: The Icon

Meet The Family

21m

Meet The Family

The Prison Within

1h 23m

The Prison Within

Anthony Ramos On 'The Good & The Bad' (Extended Cut)

12m

Anthony Ramos On 'The Good & The Bad' (Extended Cut)

End of the Line: The Women of Standing Rock

1h 27m

End of the Line: The Women of Standing Rock

The Grind Never Stops When for the Queen Diva

2m

The Grind Never Stops When for the Queen Diva