Couple Stab Each Other Over 'American Idol' Finale

FUSE TV - Couple Stab Each Other Over 'American Idol' Finale

Despite the show's lowest-ever finale ratings, two people were taking the American Idol finale extremely seriously. 

An argument between 48-year-old Karen Harrelson and 57-year-old Gregory Stambaugh (who accurately represent Idol's older-leaning majority demographic) led to both being stabbed in the midst of last week's finale, according to the York Dispatch.

The at-the-time dating duo, drunk, couldn't agree who deserved the title—Candice Glover or Kree Harrison. So, one of them solved this the only way they knew how: with a knife.

But no one's copping to starting it. According to their stories, one of them went in the kitchen, grabbed a knife and stabbed the other. The person who was stabbed first took the knife and stabbed the other back. Each is claiming the other started it. 

Both are in country prison for aggravated and simple assault charges with high bails. Hers is $30,000, his $70,000 because male Idol fans are considered to be way more dangerous than a female. (Actually, he was described at the scene as "argumentative," shouting how police "only arrest the guys.")

Why couldn't they just hug it out like Candice and Kree?

American Thief

1h 15m

American Thief

The All-Americans

1h 36m

The All-Americans

Buy, Bye American

24m

Buy, Bye American

Democracy American Style

24m

Democracy American Style

Finale

21m

Finale

American Obsessions Pt.1

20m

American Obsessions Pt.1

American Obsessions Pt.2

20m

American Obsessions Pt.2

The American Rat Race

20m

The American Rat Race

The All-Americans - Trailer

2m

The All-Americans - Trailer

Finale Aftershow

23m

Finale Aftershow

Final Fight

14m

Final Fight

Final 4 Fiesta

45m

Final 4 Fiesta

Big Bad Voodoo Finale

21m

Big Bad Voodoo Finale

The Hilarious Reality of the American Rat Race

2m

The Hilarious Reality of the American Rat Race

Fluffy Breaks Even Season 1 Finale

2m

Fluffy Breaks Even Season 1 Finale

Saturday Morning Fever Finale: First Look

1m

Saturday Morning Fever Finale: First Look

Poppin' Up All Over The Place

20m

Poppin' Up All Over The Place

The Emotional Season 2 Finale: First Look

41s

The Emotional Season 2 Finale: First Look

Season 3 Finale: Fluffy's Food Adventures Recap

37s

Season 3 Finale: Fluffy's Food Adventures Recap

Have Beauty Standards Changed Over The Years?

8m

Have Beauty Standards Changed Over The Years?

Odalys and Jamie Discuss Career Over Smoothies: The 212

1m

Odalys and Jamie Discuss Career Over Smoothies: The 212

Young M.A Jumps Over Cars To Open For Beyoncé

2m

Young M.A Jumps Over Cars To Open For Beyoncé

Frugal Fashionista

44m

Frugal Fashionista

Man, I’m Getting Married

23m

Man, I’m Getting Married

Accountability: Victim or Villain

23m

Accountability: Victim or Villain

Check It

1h 24m

Check It

Check It - Trailer

1m

Check It - Trailer

Fight Factory

Fight Factory

Sin City Shakedown

41m

Sin City Shakedown

Get to Know Gil: Fluffy Fanatic

1m

Get to Know Gil: Fluffy Fanatic

Aim For Even Higher Goals After Drum Corps

1m

Aim For Even Higher Goals After Drum Corps

DaCav Hits The Stage For An Electrifying Performance

2m

DaCav Hits The Stage For An Electrifying Performance

Alex & Jaime

1h 27m

Alex & Jaime

Decisions, Decisions

23m

Decisions, Decisions

The Jakes Are Missing

1h 30m

The Jakes Are Missing

Attack Of The Tethered Strippers

8m

Attack Of The Tethered Strippers

Gloria and Emilio Estefan

22m

Gloria and Emilio Estefan

Anya - Trailer

2m

Anya - Trailer

Babysplitters

1h 43m

Babysplitters

Anya

1h 15m

Anya

Fan or Fanatic

24m

Fan or Fanatic

Skin City

42m

Skin City

Black, Brown and Red

24m

Black, Brown and Red

Bruce Springsteen: Born to Rock

41m

Bruce Springsteen: Born to Rock

A Time For RO-mance

20m

A Time For RO-mance

Does Sports Need a Time Out?

23m

Does Sports Need a Time Out?

Argentina

44m

Argentina

Football or Futbol

20m

Football or Futbol

Gringo 101

22m

Gringo 101

In Football We Trust

1h 25m

In Football We Trust

Why Is He Blowing Me Kisses?

21m

Why Is He Blowing Me Kisses?

In Football We Trust - Trailer

2m

In Football We Trust - Trailer

Muslim Girls DTF

16m

Muslim Girls DTF

Already Tomorrow in Hong Kong - Trailer

2m

Already Tomorrow in Hong Kong - Trailer

Not Quite Latino

23m

Not Quite Latino

Muslim Girls DTF - Trailer

1m

Muslim Girls DTF - Trailer

Already Tomorrow in Hong Kong

1h 3m

Already Tomorrow in Hong Kong

Not Quite Done

46m

Not Quite Done

LA's Emotional Favorite Moment From Season 1

1m

LA's Emotional Favorite Moment From Season 1

Mark Allen, Jo Koy

45m

Mark Allen, Jo Koy

Kamala Harris: Chase the Dream

40m

Kamala Harris: Chase the Dream

Comedians Learn About This Weird Pickle Law

7m

Comedians Learn About This Weird Pickle Law

Omar Apollo

20m

Omar Apollo

Girl II Goddess

22m

Girl II Goddess

The Citizen

1h 34m

The Citizen

Michael Peña

22m

Michael Peña

Fuerza Girls

43m

Fuerza Girls

New York Rapper G Fella Pens Anthem for Playoff Knicks: G-Thing

1m

New York Rapper G Fella Pens Anthem for Playoff Knicks: G-Thing

Clash of The Corps Is Putting DCI Stereotypes To Rest

1m

Clash of The Corps Is Putting DCI Stereotypes To Rest

Be Kind, Rewind

44m

Be Kind, Rewind

Who Came To Win?

20m

Who Came To Win?

The Last 24 Hours: Amy Winehouse

1h 1m

The Last 24 Hours: Amy Winehouse

Runway Showdown

45m

Runway Showdown

Rock the Runway - Pt 2

46m

Rock the Runway - Pt 2

Prince: Kiss the Rain

54m

Prince: Kiss the Rain

Rock the Runway - Pt 1

44m

Rock the Runway - Pt 1

The Last 24 Hours: Elvis Presley

58m

The Last 24 Hours: Elvis Presley

G Fella Gives A Tour of The Bronx's Arthur Avenue

5m

G Fella Gives A Tour of The Bronx's Arthur Avenue

Pole Dance Off

44m

Pole Dance Off

The Winner Is…

44m

The Winner Is…

Straight Into Compton

3m

Straight Into Compton

The Last 24 Hours: John Lennon

59m

The Last 24 Hours: John Lennon

Hanh, Solo

1h 25m

Hanh, Solo

Hoop Hoop Hooray!

20m

Hoop Hoop Hooray!

Sexy Swimsuits

44m

Sexy Swimsuits

Marshall's Oversized Bag Dilemma

2m

Marshall's Oversized Bag Dilemma

Curtain Call

45m

Curtain Call

Brand Me

44m

Brand Me

King Keruan Steps Into the World of Ghosting

1m

King Keruan Steps Into the World of Ghosting

If Clash of the Corps Stars Could Role-Play For A Day

1m

If Clash of the Corps Stars Could Role-Play For A Day

Get A Taste of G Fella's Style with His Gangster Music Video

4m

Get A Taste of G Fella's Style with His Gangster Music Video

Wild Style

22m

Wild Style

Culture Clashin’

22m

Culture Clashin’

Crate Diggers

Crate Diggers

Goomahs

21m

Goomahs

Crate Diggers - Trailer

31s

Crate Diggers - Trailer

Shine True - Trailer

1m

Shine True - Trailer

Drama and Trauma

46m

Drama and Trauma

Copwatch - Trailer

1m

Copwatch - Trailer

Copwatch

1h 36m

Copwatch