When you first watched The Lizzie McGuire Movie, Paolo, the Italian pop star that whisks Hilary Duff away on his Vespa, seems like a dreamboat. That is, until we found out he was a manipulative lip-syncher!

Youtuber ElleOfTheMills recut the film into a thriller trailer to shed some light on Paolo's true villainous character, quickly editing together some creepy scenes. In the new clip, you know that Paolo's up to no good.

The scariest part of it? When Lizzie's mom (played iconicly by Hallie Todd) lifts up the sheets to find that her daughter is gone. Bum bum BUMMMM!!!!

The Youtube will have you going from singing, "Hey now, hey now, this is what dreams are made of" to "Hey now, hey now, this is what nightmares are made of."

Watch that above and check out our nostalgia podcast, Besterday, below: