Judge Dismisses Part of Velvet Underground's Warhol Banana Lawsuit
This lawsuit is bananas. B-A-N-A-N-A-S.
Okay, sorry for linking alt-rock forefathers (& alt-drumming foremother Moe Tucker) the Velvet Underground to Gwen Stefani's cheerleading chant, but seriously, this lawsuit is bizarre.
Earlier this year, the Velvet Underground—which disbanded forty years ago and has only reunited twice since then—filed a lawsuit against the Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts. It seems that despite their mutual enmity, founding members Lou Reed and John Cale agreed they were not happy seeing their first album's iconic banana image—which was designed by Warhol—being licensed to iPod products. For these two rock n' roll cynics, Apple using their album cover was a big ba-no-no.
So they filed suit against Warhol's Foundation, although they didn't claim they owned the banana image. Rather, they argued the album cover was public domain and therefore ineligible for licensing. But they soon changed their approach, dropped the public domain argument and instead argued the Warhol Foundation couldn't claim a copyright over the image.
But it seems the VU may have slipped up on the banana peel lawsuit. Citing the initial public domain argument and the band's reticence to claim copyright over the image for themselves, the Warhol Foundation argued there simply isn't a controversy in this lawsuit. The Foundation also offered the band a covenant not to sue if the Velvets license the banana for their own purposes.
Agreeing with those points, a federal judge in New York tossed the copyright portion of the lawsuit. But it ain't over yet: The trademark issue still remains. The Velvet Underground argue that the banana image is so closely identified with the band, anyone who sees the image licensed on a product may understandably (but incorrectly) assume the VU has endorsed said product. In that regard, they may get somewhere. So this lawsuit may still prove fruitful for the band.
21m
22m
21m
45m
5m
4m
5m
14m
23m
22m
44m
20m
1h 34m
1h 27m
45s
19m
21m
20m
41m
1h 3m
44m
23m
59m
20m
20m
21m
5m
8m
1h 33m
15s
59m
1m
40m
1h 49m
22m
18m
20m
41m
41m
2m
20m
20m
1h 1m
1h 39m
41m
2m
59s
2m
2m
42m
2m
3m
1m
40m
59m
41m
21m
20m
20m
1m
30s
1m
45s
2m
1m
23m
1m
30s
29s
21m
46s
1m
2m
29s
1m
2m
1m
2m
1m
5m
1m
2m
3m
9m
1m
5m
1m
1m
1m
3m
14m
1m
41s
1m
1m