Why I Paid $37,100 for One Record

FUSE TV - Why I Paid $37,100 for One Record

It's fitting that when I first try to reach John Tefteller, he was negotiating a rare record deal and asked to call me back. I called Tefteller, an Oregon-based record dealer whose collection numbers more than 400,000 45s, 78s and LPs, after hearing of his astounding purchase of bluesman Tommy Johnson's "Alcohol and Jake Blues" for $37,100. It's the most anyone has ever spent on a 78 rpm record and one of the highest prices paid for any record.

Tefteller, who makes his living buying and selling records and dealing blues memorabilia, has been collecting records for more than 40 years, but even he couldn't believe his luck upon discovering a near-perfect copy of "Alcohol and Jake Blues." The record is considered a Holy Grail among blues record collectors and stands as a vital historical document of the genre. 

One night, as he does every night, Tefteller was trawling eBay when he came across the record from a seller in South Carolina. The anonymous seller found the record at an estate sale years ago, and posted it on eBay with no knowledge of the record's true value. The record was set to sell at $16,800 when, minutes before the auction ended, it shot up to $37,000. Tefteller won't reveal what his maximum bid was, but suffice to say, it was enough to edge past the highest bidder and get him the record.

Soon, Tefteller will remaster the record and release it for free as part of an upcoming compilation album. But for now, the record aficionado gave us details on the record, the sale and why he actually got a pretty good deal. 

$37,100?! 

[Laughs]

What makes the record worth that much?

These original Paramount delta blues records have attained such a mythic status over the years, and there are loads of people who would love to buy one of these things, that it just becomes so legendary. When you actually see one for sale, which happens once or twice in a lifetime, you have to make a decision.

It's also historically extremely important because there are no masters on these records. You think of modern-day records and there are master tapes that you can go back to and make new copies of. When you go back to these 1920s and '30s blues recordings, this is it. The masters were destroyed years ago and there's no way to recover them. The only way anyone is able to hear this stuff now is to search out an [original] commercial pressing. So when you find one of these blues records in really super nice condition, that's an earth-shaking event in the record collecting world.

Looking at it that way, it sounds like it's difficult to put a price tag on it.

Well, that's exactly the point. When someone is shocked or awed to see that a record sold for $37,100, because that is a large amount of money in anybody's bank account, on one hand you could say, "That's nuts. Why would someone do that? That's crazy!" But when you think of the historical importance of what this is, how do you put a price on it? It's an amazing masterpiece of a record that previous to this copy, there was only one other, which I also had.

Wait, you already owned a copy?

Yup. My original copy never sounded real good; it was in hammered condition. This new copy is in beautiful condition and there's almost no wear on it. I have a lot of very rare records.

How much did you pay for that copy?

It was several thousand dollars. I'm not sure because I'm not home, so I don't know exactly. I know it sounds weird to most people because if you paid several thousand dollars for a record, you'd darn well know exactly how much you paid. But in my world of buying records for thousands of dollars on a routine basis,  it's very easy to forget exactly how much you paid for one.

We think you'll enjoy these related videos below and for more great content featuring your favorite artists, sign up for Fuse+ to access all our videos.

Interviews: Cher Lloyd on Why She Chose T.I. For "I Wish"

2m

Interviews: Cher Lloyd on Why She Chose T.I. For "I Wish"

Interviews: Joey Bada$$ On Why His First "Unorthodox" Recording Session Wasn't Right

1m

Interviews: Joey Bada$$ On Why His First "Unorthodox" Recording Session Wasn't Right

Linkin Park | On The Record

2m

Linkin Park | On The Record

Interviews: JD & the Straight Shot on Recording for TV Shows 'Lawless,' 'Hell on Wheels'

3m

Interviews: JD & the Straight Shot on Recording for TV Shows 'Lawless,' 'Hell on Wheels'

Interviews: Yo Gotti Reveals Why He Signed To Epic Records

3m

Interviews: Yo Gotti Reveals Why He Signed To Epic Records

Interviews: Iggy Azalea on Nas Making Her Tough, Why T.I. Signed Her

4m

Interviews: Iggy Azalea on Nas Making Her Tough, Why T.I. Signed Her

Festivals: Paid Dues 2013: Scarface: "I Wanna Release An Album, But I'm Scared to Death"

3m

Festivals: Paid Dues 2013: Scarface: "I Wanna Release An Album, But I'm Scared to Death"

I Played One on TV

46m

I Played One on TV

Interviews: Serj Tankian On His “Unplanned Pregnancy of a Record” & Creating Own iPad App

3m

Interviews: Serj Tankian On His “Unplanned Pregnancy of a Record” & Creating Own iPad App

Interviews: Denver Rockers Churchill on Landing Record Deal

2m

Interviews: Denver Rockers Churchill on Landing Record Deal

Interviews: Slayer on Recording New Album, Rick Rubin Snub

3m

Interviews: Slayer on Recording New Album, Rick Rubin Snub

Shows: Top 100 Hottest Hooks: Dont Worry...Gabe Saporta Has Info On Fuse Latest Top 100 Countdown

20s

Shows: Top 100 Hottest Hooks: Dont Worry...Gabe Saporta Has Info On Fuse Latest Top 100 Countdown

Interviews: T.I. on Performing

1m

Interviews: T.I. on Performing

Interviews: Christina Aguilera on Why She's Leaving 'The Voice'

2m

Interviews: Christina Aguilera on Why She's Leaving 'The Voice'

Linkin Park's Mike Shinoda On Writing Their New Record & More

2m

Linkin Park's Mike Shinoda On Writing Their New Record & More

Festivals: Paid Dues 2013: Mobb Deep Promise "Songs We Never Did Before" on New Tour

2m

Festivals: Paid Dues 2013: Mobb Deep Promise "Songs We Never Did Before" on New Tour

J. Cole on TLC Collabo: "They're Doing What I Love Them For"

1m

J. Cole on TLC Collabo: "They're Doing What I Love Them For"

Why Freedia Picked Café Reconcile For Her Pop-Up Restaurant

2m

Why Freedia Picked Café Reconcile For Her Pop-Up Restaurant

Marcedes Lewis On Why RandB Relaxes Him Before Games

46s

Marcedes Lewis On Why RandB Relaxes Him Before Games

Interviews: Armored Saint on the "Saving Grace" of Metal Blade Records

4m

Interviews: Armored Saint on the "Saving Grace" of Metal Blade Records

Eve Pawned Jewelry for Bus Rides to Record Labels: My Hustle

47s

Eve Pawned Jewelry for Bus Rides to Record Labels: My Hustle

Interviews: J. Cole on TLC Collabo "They're Doing What I Love Them For"

1m

Interviews: J. Cole on TLC Collabo "They're Doing What I Love Them For"

Shows: 100 Most Award-Winning Artists :  NELLY PICKS 100-91 Kendrick

32s

Shows: 100 Most Award-Winning Artists : NELLY PICKS 100-91 Kendrick

Shows: 100 Pop Breakthroughs: Tyso Rritter Fav video 100 to 91

45s

Shows: 100 Pop Breakthroughs: Tyso Rritter Fav video 100 to 91

Shows: 100 Most Award-Winning Artists:  Cody Simpson vs. Teleprompter: "One More Time, One More Time!"   BTS

2m

Shows: 100 Most Award-Winning Artists: Cody Simpson vs. Teleprompter: "One More Time, One More Time!" BTS

Interviews: T.I. on Retirement (October 2014)

1m

Interviews: T.I. on Retirement (October 2014)

Interviews: T.I. on Album (October 2014)

3m

Interviews: T.I. on Album (October 2014)

Shows: Top 100 Hottest Hooks: Ashanti Preps You For Fuse's Hottest Hooks Countdown

19s

Shows: Top 100 Hottest Hooks: Ashanti Preps You For Fuse's Hottest Hooks Countdown

Shows: Top 20: Why Passion Pit's Michael Angelakos Went on a "Twiatus"

1m

Shows: Top 20: Why Passion Pit's Michael Angelakos Went on a "Twiatus"

Interviews: Cher Lloyd on Vile Tweets and Why She's Not a Partier

3m

Interviews: Cher Lloyd on Vile Tweets and Why She's Not a Partier

Shows: Top 100 Sexy Beats: Top 100 Sexy Beats Flo Rida 40-31

29s

Shows: Top 100 Sexy Beats: Top 100 Sexy Beats Flo Rida 40-31

Shows: Hoppus on Music: Santigold Describes Her Journey From Assistant to Recording Artist

1m

Shows: Hoppus on Music: Santigold Describes Her Journey From Assistant to Recording Artist

The Naked And Famous' Alisa on Recording Latest Album After Breakup With Bandmate

3m

The Naked And Famous' Alisa on Recording Latest Album After Breakup With Bandmate

Why This Show Exists?

8m

Why This Show Exists?

The Dirtiest Song Ever Recorded

21m

The Dirtiest Song Ever Recorded

Shows: Top 100 Sexy Beats: Adam Lambert Behind the Scenes Top 100 Sexy Beats

2m

Shows: Top 100 Sexy Beats: Adam Lambert Behind the Scenes Top 100 Sexy Beats

Why One Model Wouldn't Jump Off a Cliff in The Wanted's Video

47s

Why One Model Wouldn't Jump Off a Cliff in The Wanted's Video

Interviews: Fall Out Boy Explain Why They're Rooting for the Denver Broncos

1m

Interviews: Fall Out Boy Explain Why They're Rooting for the Denver Broncos

Death Cab For Cutie Aim To Record New Album With New Members In 2017

3m

Death Cab For Cutie Aim To Record New Album With New Members In 2017

Interviews: Dr. Dre Stopped Working on 'Detox' to Record With Alabama Rapper Rich Boy

3m

Interviews: Dr. Dre Stopped Working on 'Detox' to Record With Alabama Rapper Rich Boy

Shows: Top 100 Killer Collabos: Killer Collabos Recap: #100-91, Plus Which Was Keri's Favorite?

40s

Shows: Top 100 Killer Collabos: Killer Collabos Recap: #100-91, Plus Which Was Keri's Favorite?

M.I.A. Channeled a Hindu Goddess on 'Matangi'

48s

M.I.A. Channeled a Hindu Goddess on 'Matangi'

Why DJ Alle Farben Made 'Who the F-ck Is Rosie?' Shirts for Lollapalooza

1m

Why DJ Alle Farben Made 'Who the F-ck Is Rosie?' Shirts for Lollapalooza

Big Freedia Sets Twerking World Record

4m

Big Freedia Sets Twerking World Record

Interviews: German Rock Legend Herbert Grönemeyer on Recording With Bono "He's Very Humble in Private"

3m

Interviews: German Rock Legend Herbert Grönemeyer on Recording With Bono "He's Very Humble in Private"

Interviews: Tech N9ne on Rock EP 'Therapy': "I'm Singing, But I'm Not Comfortable"

2m

Interviews: Tech N9ne on Rock EP 'Therapy': "I'm Singing, But I'm Not Comfortable"

Shows: Bangin Bodies: Bodies Recap: #100 - #91

38s

Shows: Bangin Bodies: Bodies Recap: #100 - #91

Top Sexiest 100 Videos:  Chanel Iman BTS

3m

Top Sexiest 100 Videos: Chanel Iman BTS

Top Sexiest 100 Videos: Chrissy Teigen BTS

2m

Top Sexiest 100 Videos: Chrissy Teigen BTS

Top Sexiest 100 Videos: Lily Aldridge BTS

3m

Top Sexiest 100 Videos: Lily Aldridge BTS

Coachella 2014: Why Fatboy Slim Had to Make an "Alternative Soundtrack" for Brazil World Cup

4m

Coachella 2014: Why Fatboy Slim Had to Make an "Alternative Soundtrack" for Brazil World Cup

Why Is He Blowing Me Kisses?

21m

Why Is He Blowing Me Kisses?

Interviews: PRhyme Top 3 Records (December 2014)

4m

Interviews: PRhyme Top 3 Records (December 2014)

Festivals: SXSW 2013: Hit-Boy on His Dream Collabo: "That's When I'll Know I've Arrived"

2m

Festivals: SXSW 2013: Hit-Boy on His Dream Collabo: "That's When I'll Know I've Arrived"

Shows: Party Playlist : Andrew Wk Fav 100- 91

21s

Shows: Party Playlist : Andrew Wk Fav 100- 91

Tyson Ritter 40 to 31: 100 Pop Breakthroughs

51s

Tyson Ritter 40 to 31: 100 Pop Breakthroughs

Top Sexiest 100 Videos: Host Pick 60-51

20s

Top Sexiest 100 Videos: Host Pick 60-51

Interviews: Kaskade on Singing for First Time Ever on "Very Personal" New Album

3m

Interviews: Kaskade on Singing for First Time Ever on "Very Personal" New Album

Shows: Top 100 Hottest Hooks: Hour8 Taio Favs

25s

Shows: Top 100 Hottest Hooks: Hour8 Taio Favs

Top Sexiest 100 Videos: Host Pick 20-11

22s

Top Sexiest 100 Videos: Host Pick 20-11

Wiz Khalifa on Adele Collabo  "I Hope We Can Put It On the Album": Fuse News

3m

Wiz Khalifa on Adele Collabo "I Hope We Can Put It On the Album": Fuse News

Every Time I Die Talks Being Too Old For Warped Tour

2m

Every Time I Die Talks Being Too Old For Warped Tour

Interviews: A Look Inside Indie Label Glassnote Records

3m

Interviews: A Look Inside Indie Label Glassnote Records

'Fuse Fresh': Watch the Story Behind Burger Records

2m

'Fuse Fresh': Watch the Story Behind Burger Records

Festivals: Rock The Bells 2013:  Trinidad James on One-Hit Wonder Status: "I'm Still Getting Money"

3m

Festivals: Rock The Bells 2013: Trinidad James on One-Hit Wonder Status: "I'm Still Getting Money"

Interviews: Grammy: Diplo Reveals Snoop Lion Recording Details

1m

Interviews: Grammy: Diplo Reveals Snoop Lion Recording Details

Shows: 100 Most Award-Winning Artists: BTS Jack Antonoff

3m

Shows: 100 Most Award-Winning Artists: BTS Jack Antonoff

Shows: Top 100 Killer Collabos: Keri Hour 10 Twitter

38s

Shows: Top 100 Killer Collabos: Keri Hour 10 Twitter

Shows: Top 100 House Party Song: Adrienne Bailon BTS

3m

Shows: Top 100 House Party Song: Adrienne Bailon BTS

Shows: Top 100 Killer Collabos: Gabe Hour 9 Picks

37s

Shows: Top 100 Killer Collabos: Gabe Hour 9 Picks

Shows: Top 100 Hottest Hooks: Hour 10 3OH3 Favs

32s

Shows: Top 100 Hottest Hooks: Hour 10 3OH3 Favs

Shows: Top 100 House Party Song:  Pete Wentz BTS

2m

Shows: Top 100 House Party Song: Pete Wentz BTS

05 - I SWEAR I'M OKAY

4m

05 - I SWEAR I'M OKAY

Sinéad O'Connor: 'Miley Cyrus & I Are Catalysts For Mental Health Discussion'

3m

Sinéad O'Connor: 'Miley Cyrus & I Are Catalysts For Mental Health Discussion'

Interviews: Tamar Braxton "I Was Disappointed in R&B for a While"

3m

Interviews: Tamar Braxton "I Was Disappointed in R&B for a While"

Lorde "I Just Have a Low Tolerance for Stupid People": Fuse News

3m

Lorde "I Just Have a Low Tolerance for Stupid People": Fuse News

Festivals: Bonnaroo 2013: Big K.R.I.T. on Working With Spike Lee: "I Let Him Have His Way"

5m

Festivals: Bonnaroo 2013: Big K.R.I.T. on Working With Spike Lee: "I Let Him Have His Way"

Festivals:UltraFest 2013: Bassnectar  "I'm Really Behind on Pop Music"

2m

Festivals:UltraFest 2013: Bassnectar "I'm Really Behind on Pop Music"

Interviews: Brian McKnight: "I Wasn't Planning on Making Another Album"

3m

Interviews: Brian McKnight: "I Wasn't Planning on Making Another Album"

Billy Joel on his Setlists  "I'm Doing More Obscure Material": Interviews

1m

Billy Joel on his Setlists "I'm Doing More Obscure Material": Interviews

iHeart

10m

iHeart

Festivals: Paid Dues 2013: Immortal Technique Shocked to Find Out David Lee Roth Is a Fan

5m

Festivals: Paid Dues 2013: Immortal Technique Shocked to Find Out David Lee Roth Is a Fan

LunchMoney Lewis Reveals How Fast Meghan Trainor Records

1m

LunchMoney Lewis Reveals How Fast Meghan Trainor Records

Lollapalooza 2015: Cold War Kids Talk Possible Live Record

1m

Lollapalooza 2015: Cold War Kids Talk Possible Live Record

PVRIS Are Recording New Music In A Haunted Church

2m

PVRIS Are Recording New Music In A Haunted Church

Ballet Is Why Leon Bridges Is So Smooth

1m

Ballet Is Why Leon Bridges Is So Smooth

Will.I.Am: The Way I Am

3603s

Will.I.Am: The Way I Am

Interviews:All Time Low Explain Returning to Hopeless Records

5m

Interviews:All Time Low Explain Returning to Hopeless Records

Shows: Top 100 House Party Song: Adrienne Bailon  Fav Dance

31s

Shows: Top 100 House Party Song: Adrienne Bailon Fav Dance

Shows: Top 100 House Party Song: Pete Wentz Party Playlist

55s

Shows: Top 100 House Party Song: Pete Wentz Party Playlist

Shows: Top 100 Killer Collabos: Killer Collabos Recap: #70 - #61

36s

Shows: Top 100 Killer Collabos: Killer Collabos Recap: #70 - #61

Shows: Top 100 Killer Collabos: Killer Collabos Recap: #60 - #51

37s

Shows: Top 100 Killer Collabos: Killer Collabos Recap: #60 - #51

Shows: 100 Pop Breakthroughs: Tyson Ritter Switch bodies with someone

41s

Shows: 100 Pop Breakthroughs: Tyson Ritter Switch bodies with someone

Jason Derulo fav videos 20 to 11: 100 Pop Breakthroughs

41s

Jason Derulo fav videos 20 to 11: 100 Pop Breakthroughs

Shows: Top 100 House Party Song: Pete Wentz Fav Dance

28s

Shows: Top 100 House Party Song: Pete Wentz Fav Dance

Shows: Top 100 House Party Song:  Travie Mccoy Fav Dance

43s

Shows: Top 100 House Party Song: Travie Mccoy Fav Dance

Shows: Top 100 House Party Song: Travie Mccoy Party Playlist

55s

Shows: Top 100 House Party Song: Travie Mccoy Party Playlist

Shows: Top 100 House Party Song: Adrienne Bailon Party Playlist

38s

Shows: Top 100 House Party Song: Adrienne Bailon Party Playlist

Shows: Party Playlist : Rita Ora Top 100 Party Playlist BTS

2m

Shows: Party Playlist : Rita Ora Top 100 Party Playlist BTS

Alison Wonderland Explains Why She Feels Awkward Collaborating

2m

Alison Wonderland Explains Why She Feels Awkward Collaborating