Why I Paid $37,100 for One Record

Why I Paid $37,100 for One Record

FUSE TV - Why I Paid $37,100 for One Record

It's fitting that when I first try to reach John Tefteller, he was negotiating a rare record deal and asked to call me back. I called Tefteller, an Oregon-based record dealer whose collection numbers more than 400,000 45s, 78s and LPs, after hearing of his astounding purchase of bluesman Tommy Johnson's "Alcohol and Jake Blues" for $37,100. It's the most anyone has ever spent on a 78 rpm record and one of the highest prices paid for any record.

Tefteller, who makes his living buying and selling records and dealing blues memorabilia, has been collecting records for more than 40 years, but even he couldn't believe his luck upon discovering a near-perfect copy of "Alcohol and Jake Blues." The record is considered a Holy Grail among blues record collectors and stands as a vital historical document of the genre. 

One night, as he does every night, Tefteller was trawling eBay when he came across the record from a seller in South Carolina. The anonymous seller found the record at an estate sale years ago, and posted it on eBay with no knowledge of the record's true value. The record was set to sell at $16,800 when, minutes before the auction ended, it shot up to $37,000. Tefteller won't reveal what his maximum bid was, but suffice to say, it was enough to edge past the highest bidder and get him the record.

Soon, Tefteller will remaster the record and release it for free as part of an upcoming compilation album. But for now, the record aficionado gave us details on the record, the sale and why he actually got a pretty good deal. 

$37,100?! 

[Laughs]

What makes the record worth that much?

These original Paramount delta blues records have attained such a mythic status over the years, and there are loads of people who would love to buy one of these things, that it just becomes so legendary. When you actually see one for sale, which happens once or twice in a lifetime, you have to make a decision.

It's also historically extremely important because there are no masters on these records. You think of modern-day records and there are master tapes that you can go back to and make new copies of. When you go back to these 1920s and '30s blues recordings, this is it. The masters were destroyed years ago and there's no way to recover them. The only way anyone is able to hear this stuff now is to search out an [original] commercial pressing. So when you find one of these blues records in really super nice condition, that's an earth-shaking event in the record collecting world.

Looking at it that way, it sounds like it's difficult to put a price tag on it.

Well, that's exactly the point. When someone is shocked or awed to see that a record sold for $37,100, because that is a large amount of money in anybody's bank account, on one hand you could say, "That's nuts. Why would someone do that? That's crazy!" But when you think of the historical importance of what this is, how do you put a price on it? It's an amazing masterpiece of a record that previous to this copy, there was only one other, which I also had.

Wait, you already owned a copy?

Yup. My original copy never sounded real good; it was in hammered condition. This new copy is in beautiful condition and there's almost no wear on it. I have a lot of very rare records.

How much did you pay for that copy?

It was several thousand dollars. I'm not sure because I'm not home, so I don't know exactly. I know it sounds weird to most people because if you paid several thousand dollars for a record, you'd darn well know exactly how much you paid. But in my world of buying records for thousands of dollars on a routine basis,  it's very easy to forget exactly how much you paid for one.

Sorry, the article you’re looking for is no longer available! Try these recommended videos.

Grimes On Why She Started Recording Herself

1m

Grimes On Why She Started Recording Herself

Interviews: Cher Lloyd on Why She Chose T.I. For "I Wish"

2m

Interviews: Cher Lloyd on Why She Chose T.I. For "I Wish"

Top 100 Hip Hop Hits: Why Khaled Loves T.I.'s "Live Your Life"

47s

Top 100 Hip Hop Hits: Why Khaled Loves T.I.'s "Live Your Life"

Top 100 Hip Hop Hits: Why Naturi Loves B.o.B's "Nothin' On You"

32s

Top 100 Hip Hop Hits: Why Naturi Loves B.o.B's "Nothin' On You"

Interviews: Joey Bada$$ On Why His First "Unorthodox" Recording Session Wasn't Right

1m

Interviews: Joey Bada$$ On Why His First "Unorthodox" Recording Session Wasn't Right

T.I. On Why The Ladies Love Him

3m

T.I. On Why The Ladies Love Him

Shows: On The Record: Mariah Carey Has a Lesson for Children On the Record With Fuse Bonus Feature

1m

Shows: On The Record: Mariah Carey Has a Lesson for Children On the Record With Fuse Bonus Feature

Interviews: JD & the Straight Shot on Recording for TV Shows 'Lawless,' 'Hell on Wheels'

3m

Interviews: JD & the Straight Shot on Recording for TV Shows 'Lawless,' 'Hell on Wheels'

Interviews: Serj Tankian On His “Unplanned Pregnancy of a Record” & Creating Own iPad App

3m

Interviews: Serj Tankian On His “Unplanned Pregnancy of a Record” & Creating Own iPad App

Diddy - On the Record

19m

Diddy - On the Record

Interviews: Iggy Azalea on Nas Making Her Tough, Why T.I. Signed Her

4m

Interviews: Iggy Azalea on Nas Making Her Tough, Why T.I. Signed Her

Nathan Sykes on Recording What Felt 'Right & Natural' for Solo LP

2m

Nathan Sykes on Recording What Felt 'Right & Natural' for Solo LP

Shows: Mariah Carey Has a Lesson for Children: On the Record With Fuse Bonus Feature

1m

Shows: Mariah Carey Has a Lesson for Children: On the Record With Fuse Bonus Feature

Festivals: Paid Dues 2013:  Rapper Tech N9ne Recorded New Song With The Doors!!!

3m

Festivals: Paid Dues 2013: Rapper Tech N9ne Recorded New Song With The Doors!!!

Festivals: Paid Dues 2013: Fashawn "Murs Is Adamant About Continuing" to Record Together

4m

Festivals: Paid Dues 2013: Fashawn "Murs Is Adamant About Continuing" to Record Together

On The Record Exclusive : Rihanna

3m

On The Record Exclusive : Rihanna

Joss Stone On Recording Covers

4m

Joss Stone On Recording Covers

Linkin Park | On The Record

2m

Linkin Park | On The Record

Top 100 Hip Hop Hits: Why Naturi Loves Usher's "OMG"

35s

Top 100 Hip Hop Hits: Why Naturi Loves Usher's "OMG"

Linkin Park: On the Record

19m

Linkin Park: On the Record

Ice Cube - On the Record

19m

Ice Cube - On the Record

Festivals: Paid Dues 2013: Scarface: "I Wanna Release An Album, But I'm Scared to Death"

3m

Festivals: Paid Dues 2013: Scarface: "I Wanna Release An Album, But I'm Scared to Death"

Yo Gotti Reveals Why He Signed To Epic Records

3m

Yo Gotti Reveals Why He Signed To Epic Records

Interviews: Yo Gotti Reveals Why He Signed To Epic Records

3m

Interviews: Yo Gotti Reveals Why He Signed To Epic Records

On The Record: Linkin Park - Influences

1m

On The Record: Linkin Park - Influences

On The Record : Snoop Dogg - Part 3

5m

On The Record : Snoop Dogg - Part 3

On The Record : Snoop Dogg - Part 2

7m

On The Record : Snoop Dogg - Part 2

On The Record Exclusive : Ceelo Green

52s

On The Record Exclusive : Ceelo Green

On The Record: J.Lo - Part 3

5m

On The Record: J.Lo - Part 3

On The Record: Linkin Park - Part 3

4m

On The Record: Linkin Park - Part 3

On The Record Exclusive : 50 Cent

1m

On The Record Exclusive : 50 Cent

On The Record : Snoop Dogg - Part 1

6m

On The Record : Snoop Dogg - Part 1

On The Record - Lady Gaga Pt. 2

6m

On The Record - Lady Gaga Pt. 2

Shows: On The Record: Anthony Meets Flea

2m

Shows: On The Record: Anthony Meets Flea

On The Record: Ludacris - Part 3

6m

On The Record: Ludacris - Part 3

On The Record Exclusive : Rihanna - Part 2

1m

On The Record Exclusive : Rihanna - Part 2

Macklemore & Ryan Lewis on Recording "The Heist"

3m

Macklemore & Ryan Lewis on Recording "The Heist"

On The Record : 50 Cent - Part 3

3m

On The Record : 50 Cent - Part 3

On The Record: Linkin Park - Part 2

7m

On The Record: Linkin Park - Part 2

On The Record: Diddy - Pt. 1

6m

On The Record: Diddy - Pt. 1

On The Record : Ceelo Green - Part 3

4m

On The Record : Ceelo Green - Part 3

On The Record : 50 Cent - Part 2

8m

On The Record : 50 Cent - Part 2

On The Record: Diddy - Pt. 2

7m

On The Record: Diddy - Pt. 2

On The Record Exclusive : Ludacris - Part 1

2m

On The Record Exclusive : Ludacris - Part 1

On The Record : Rihanna - Part 3

4m

On The Record : Rihanna - Part 3

On The Record : Christina Aguilera - Part 3

6m

On The Record : Christina Aguilera - Part 3

On The Record: Linkin Park - Part 1

7m

On The Record: Linkin Park - Part 1

Shows: On The Record: Mariah Carey on Acting: On the Record With Fuse Bonus Feature

4m

Shows: On The Record: Mariah Carey on Acting: On the Record With Fuse Bonus Feature

Shows: On The Record: Musical Relationship

1m

Shows: On The Record: Musical Relationship

On The Record: J.Lo - Part 2

7m

On The Record: J.Lo - Part 2

On The Record: Linkin Park - Chemistry

1m

On The Record: Linkin Park - Chemistry

On The Record Exclusive : Ludacris - Part 2

2m

On The Record Exclusive : Ludacris - Part 2

On The Record : Rihanna - Part 2

7m

On The Record : Rihanna - Part 2

On The Record : Ceelo Green - Part 2

7m

On The Record : Ceelo Green - Part 2

Michael Kwanuka On Reviews and Recording

1m

Michael Kwanuka On Reviews and Recording

50 Cent On Recording 'Champions' With Eminem

1m

50 Cent On Recording 'Champions' With Eminem

On The Record: Diddy - Pt. 3

6m

On The Record: Diddy - Pt. 3

On The Record : 50 Cent - Part 1

7m

On The Record : 50 Cent - Part 1

On The Record : Rihanna - Part 1

7m

On The Record : Rihanna - Part 1

Lady Gaga's Judas - On The Record Exclusive

47s

Lady Gaga's Judas - On The Record Exclusive

On The Record - Lady Gaga Pt. 3

6m

On The Record - Lady Gaga Pt. 3

On The Record : Christina Aguilera - Part 1

7m

On The Record : Christina Aguilera - Part 1

On The Record: J.Lo - Part 1

6m

On The Record: J.Lo - Part 1

On The Record: Ludacris - Part 1

7m

On The Record: Ludacris - Part 1

On The Record: Ludacris - Part 2

6m

On The Record: Ludacris - Part 2

On The Record : Christina Aguilera - Part 2

5m

On The Record : Christina Aguilera - Part 2

On The Record: Kid Rock Pt. 3

1m

On The Record: Kid Rock Pt. 3

On The Record : Foo Fighters - Exclusive

2m

On The Record : Foo Fighters - Exclusive

Shows: On The Record:The "Real" Jennifer - Jennifer Lopez On The Record Extra

1m

Shows: On The Record:The "Real" Jennifer - Jennifer Lopez On The Record Extra

Shows: On The Record: Predicting the Future - Black Eyed Peas On The Record Exclusive

1m

Shows: On The Record: Predicting the Future - Black Eyed Peas On The Record Exclusive

Shows: On The Record: 'The Beginning' - Black Eyed Peas On The Record Exclusive

1m

Shows: On The Record: 'The Beginning' - Black Eyed Peas On The Record Exclusive

Shows: On The Record: Fergie's Impressions - Black Eyed Peas On The Record Exclusive

56s

Shows: On The Record: Fergie's Impressions - Black Eyed Peas On The Record Exclusive

Top 100 Hip Hop Hits: Why Royce Loves Eminem's "Not Afraid"

37s

Top 100 Hip Hop Hits: Why Royce Loves Eminem's "Not Afraid"

Top 100 Hip Hop Hits: Why Naturi Loves Jay-Z's "Empire State of Mind"

40s

Top 100 Hip Hop Hits: Why Naturi Loves Jay-Z's "Empire State of Mind"

Festivals: Paid Dues 2013: Mobb Deep Promise "Songs We Never Did Before" on New Tour

2m

Festivals: Paid Dues 2013: Mobb Deep Promise "Songs We Never Did Before" on New Tour

Top 100 Hip Hop Hits: Why DJ Khaled Loves Drake's "Successful"

49s

Top 100 Hip Hop Hits: Why DJ Khaled Loves Drake's "Successful"

Shows: On The Record: Kids & Motherhood - Jennifer Lopez On The Record Extra

57s

Shows: On The Record: Kids & Motherhood - Jennifer Lopez On The Record Extra

Shows: On The Record: Jennifer Lopez Extended Interview - On The Record Extra

4m

Shows: On The Record: Jennifer Lopez Extended Interview - On The Record Extra

Shows: On The Record: Black Eyed Peas Extented Interview - On The Record Exclusive

4m

Shows: On The Record: Black Eyed Peas Extented Interview - On The Record Exclusive

J. Cole on TLC Collabo: "They're Doing What I Love Them For"

1m

J. Cole on TLC Collabo: "They're Doing What I Love Them For"

Top 100 Hip Hop Hits: Why Naturi Loves Beyonce's "Single Ladies"

40s

Top 100 Hip Hop Hits: Why Naturi Loves Beyonce's "Single Ladies"

Shows: On The Record: Not Just a "Latin" Actress - Jennifer Lopez On The Record Extra

1m

Shows: On The Record: Not Just a "Latin" Actress - Jennifer Lopez On The Record Extra

Shows: On The Record: Building a Fan Base - Black Eyed Peas On The Record Exclusive

57s

Shows: On The Record: Building a Fan Base - Black Eyed Peas On The Record Exclusive

Top 100 Hip Hop Hits: Why "Fly" Moved Nicki Minaj Instantly

36s

Top 100 Hip Hop Hits: Why "Fly" Moved Nicki Minaj Instantly

Top 100 Hip Hop Hits: Why Royce Thinks His Song "Lighters" Is a Hit

33s

Top 100 Hip Hop Hits: Why Royce Thinks His Song "Lighters" Is a Hit

Top 100 Hip Hop Hits: Why Royce Loves Jay-Z's "Big Pimpin'"

36s

Top 100 Hip Hop Hits: Why Royce Loves Jay-Z's "Big Pimpin'"

Lady Gaga on Writing a Song - On The Record Exclusive

1m

Lady Gaga on Writing a Song - On The Record Exclusive

Shows: Top 100:  Rutina Wesley Behind The Scenes - Top 100 Number Ones

1m

Shows: Top 100: Rutina Wesley Behind The Scenes - Top 100 Number Ones

Interviews: J. Cole on TLC Collabo "They're Doing What I Love Them For"

1m

Interviews: J. Cole on TLC Collabo "They're Doing What I Love Them For"

Jadakiss On A Why Sequel: The Bridge

53s

Jadakiss On A Why Sequel: The Bridge

Shows: Top 100: Harry Shum Jr. Behind The Scenes - Top 100 Number Ones

2m

Shows: Top 100: Harry Shum Jr. Behind The Scenes - Top 100 Number Ones

Shows: Top 100:  The Hosts Pick Their Favorite Number One Artist - Top 100 Number Ones on Fuse

2m

Shows: Top 100: The Hosts Pick Their Favorite Number One Artist - Top 100 Number Ones on Fuse

Shows: Top 100:  Nick Cannon Behind The Scenes - Top 100 Number Ones

1m

Shows: Top 100: Nick Cannon Behind The Scenes - Top 100 Number Ones

Shows: Top 100:  The Greatest Dance Move of the 2000s - Top 100 Number Ones

59s

Shows: Top 100: The Greatest Dance Move of the 2000s - Top 100 Number Ones

I Played One on TV

46m

I Played One on TV

On The Record Exclusive : Snoop Dogg - Part 2

2m

On The Record Exclusive : Snoop Dogg - Part 2

Shows: On The Record : Adam Lambert - Part 3

5m

Shows: On The Record : Adam Lambert - Part 3

Nipsey Hussle On The Theory Behind His 100 Album

1m

Nipsey Hussle On The Theory Behind His 100 Album

Shows: On The Record : Adam Lambert - Part 2

6m

Shows: On The Record : Adam Lambert - Part 2

Middle Class Rut On Their New Approach To Record-Making

3m

Middle Class Rut On Their New Approach To Record-Making